Differences in religious believes, values and ways of thinking could lead to conflicts among nations and states; and conflicts could lead to wars. However, are conflicts inevitable? Couldn't they be pacified without warring for cultural differences? We must needs to find resources of thinking in all national cultures advocating the coexistence of civilizations, in order to counteract those cultural elements possible to invite conflicts. As argued above, the Confucianism and Taoism in Chinese culture could provide significant resources of thinking to counteract the clash of civilizations and to bring forth the coexistence of civilizations. I believe the same kind of resources could be found in cultures of all nations and states too. When human civilization is on threshold of the 21st century, should we practice a theory of "clash of civilizations" to deal with the problems among nations and states, or a theory of "coexistence of civilizations" to guide human society on a road leading to peaceful coexistence instead? This is a question. We must ponder at it seriously and make a thoughtful choice. It would be the blessing of human being if it chooses not the clash but the coexistence of civilizations. The Book of History told us: "All the states under Heaven should be harmonized."[46] As many other nations, the Chinese is a great one with a long and brilliant tradition of history and culture, which is undoubtedly a most valuable treasure for mankind. We should make good use of this treasure, exert its proper contributions to the peaceful coexistence of human society, in order that harmony might befall on the world, pushing forward the global cultural exchanges。
-- "Clash"or"Coexistence" of Civilizations? Tang Yijie From:(Beijing Forum) Translated by: YANG, Zhiyi
中文:
照我看,也许我们正处在一个新的轴心时代。德国哲学家雅斯贝尔斯曾经提出"轴心时代"的观念。他认为,在公元前五百年前后,在古希腊、以色列、印度和中国几乎同时出现了伟大的思想家,他们都对人类关切的问题提出了独到看法。古希腊有苏格拉底、柏拉图,中国有老子、孔子,印度有释迦牟尼,以色列有犹太教的先知们,形成了不同的文化传统。这些文化传统经过两千多年的发展已经成为人类文化的主要精神财富,而且这些地域的不同文化,原来都是独立发展出来的,并没有互相影响。"人类一直靠轴心时代所产生的思考和创造的一切而生存,每一次新的飞跃都回顾这一时期,并被它重新燃起火焰。自那以后,情况就是这样。轴心期潜力的苏醒和对轴心期潜力的回忆或曰复兴,总是提供了精神动力。"例如,欧洲的文艺复兴就是把目光投向其文化的源头古希腊,使欧洲文明重新燃起火焰,而对世界产生重大影响。中国的宋明理学(新儒学)在受到印度佛教文化冲击后,再次回到先秦的孔孟,而把中国本土哲学提高到一个新水平。在某种意义上说,当今世界多种文化的发展很可能是对二千多年前的轴心时代又一次新的飞跃。
中国文化能否为"文明的共存"作贡献
化解冲突,需要我们从各个不同民族的文化中找出文明共存的资源。中国文化中的儒道两家可以为化解"文明的冲突"、实现"文明的共存"提供有意义的资源。